In partnership with
The clock is ticking. If you're selling real estate before year-end, the difference between closing on December 30th vs January 2nd could cost you $15,000 to $50,000+ in unnecessary taxes. This isn't about minor tax optimization—it's about major wealth preservation that depends entirely on understanding how your income changes and available losses will affect your 2025 vs 2026 tax liability.
🎯 Your Decision Hinges on These 4 Critical Factors:
Income Direction: Will you earn more or less in 2026 than 2025?
Available Losses: Do you have investment losses to offset gains this year vs next?
Tax Bracket Impact: Will your gain push you into a higher capital gains bracket?
Primary Residence Status: Does the $250K/$500K exclusion apply to your sale?
Capital Gains Rates: 2025 vs 2026 Comparison
The foundation of your decision starts with understanding how tax brackets will shift between years:
Tax Rate | 2025 Thresholds | 2026 Projected Thresholds | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
0% Rate | Single: Up to $48,350 | Single: Up to $49,450 | +$1,100/+$2,200 |
15% Rate | Single: $48,351-$533,400 | Single: $49,451-$545,500 | Brackets widen |
20% Rate + 3.8% NIIT | Above $533,400/$600,050 | Above $545,500/$613,700 | 23.8% effective rate |
Key Insight: The slight threshold increases in 2026 mean some taxpayers could benefit from deferring gains, but income changes matter far more than bracket adjustments.
Your Income Trajectory Changes Everything
Here's where strategic timing can save or cost you tens of thousands. Let me show you exactly how different income scenarios play out:
Scenario A: Income Increasing in 2026 (Promotion, Business Growth, Spouse Returns to Work)
Example: Software executive selling rental property
2025 Income: $180,000 (15% capital gains bracket)
2026 Income: $250,000 (still 15% bracket, but closer to 20%)
Property Gain: $200,000
December 2025 Close:
Total income: $380,000 (salary + gain) = 15% rate
Capital gains tax: $30,000
January 2026 Close:
Total income: $450,000 (higher salary + gain) = 15% rate
Capital gains tax: $30,000
Result: No difference in this case, but you're approaching the 20% threshold faster in 2026.
Scenario B: Income Decreasing in 2026 (Retirement, Career Change, Business Slowdown)
Example: Business owner retiring mid-2026
2025 Income: $400,000 (20% capital gains bracket)
2026 Income: $80,000 (15% capital gains bracket)
Property Gain: $300,000
December 2025 Close:
Tax rate: 20% + 3.8% NIIT = 23.8%
Capital gains tax: $71,400
January 2026 Close:
Total income: $380,000 (reduced salary + gain) = 15% rate
Capital gains tax: $45,000
Result: SAVE $26,400 by waiting until January!
Scenario C: Using 2025 Losses to Offset Gains
Example: Investor with stock market losses in 2025
Property Gain: $250,000
Available 2025 Stock Losses: $100,000
Net Taxable Gain if Closed in 2025: $150,000
December 2025 Close:
Taxable gain after losses: $150,000
Tax (at 15%): $22,500
January 2026 Close:
Full gain taxable: $250,000 (losses can't offset across years)
Tax (at 15%): $37,500
Result: SAVE $15,000 by closing in December to use 2025 losses!
Scenario D: Harvesting 2026 Losses Strategically
Example: Portfolio rebalancing planned for early 2026
Property Gain: $200,000
Planned 2026 Stock Sales (losses): $75,000
Strategy: Time both transactions in 2026
January 2026 Close + Loss Harvesting:
Net taxable gain: $125,000
Tax savings: $11,250
Plus additional benefit: Reset cost basis on loss positions while maintaining portfolio allocation.
Decision Framework: Should You Close in December or January?
🔄 Close in DECEMBER 2025 if:
✅ You have significant investment losses available in 2025 to offset gains
✅ Your 2026 income will be substantially higher (promotion, business growth)
✅ You're already in the 0% bracket and gain won't push you to 15%
✅ You need the proceeds for 2025 tax planning or year-end investments
✅ Your primary residence exclusion period is expiring
⏳ Close in JANUARY 2026 if:
✅ Your 2026 income will be significantly lower (retirement, sabbatical)
✅ You're close to qualifying for primary residence exclusion ($500K tax-free)
✅ You plan to harvest losses in early 2026 to offset the gain
✅ The gain would push you from 15% to 20% bracket in 2025 but not 2026
✅ You're implementing an installment sale strategy
Real Dollar Impact Examples
💰 Success Story: The $31,400 Retirement Timing Save
Client Situation: Doctor retiring January 2026, selling medical office building
Property gain: $400,000
2025 income: $450,000 → 2026 income: $50,000
December close cost: $95,200 (23.8% rate)
January close cost: $63,800 (15.9% blended rate)
Savings by waiting 2 days: $31,400
⚠️ Costly Mistake: The $18,000 Loss Harvesting Miss
Client Situation: Tech investor with 2025 crypto losses
Real estate gain: $220,000
Available 2025 crypto losses: $120,000
They waited until January: Couldn't use 2025 losses, paid $33,000
Should have closed in December: Net gain $100,000, paid $15,000
Cost of poor timing: $18,000
Special Considerations You Can't Ignore
Primary Residence Exclusion: Your $125,000 Tax Shield
If this is your primary residence, you can exclude up to $250,000 (single) or $500,000 (married) of gain from taxes. Requirements:
Owned for at least 2 of the last 5 years
Used as primary residence for at least 2 of the last 5 years
Haven't used the exclusion in the past 2 years
Timing Tip: If you're 1-2 months short of the 2-year requirement, waiting until 2026 could save you $75,000-$125,000 in taxes on a typical home sale gain.
Depreciation Recapture: The 25% Trap
If you've claimed depreciation on rental property, you'll owe 25% tax on all depreciation claimed, regardless of your income level. This applies to both December and January closings—no timing advantage here.
🎯 Your Action Checklist (Complete by December 15th)
□ Calculate your 2025 vs 2026 projected income (include all sources)
□ Inventory available tax losses in both 2025 and planned for 2026
□ Determine your exact capital gains tax bracket for both scenarios
□ Verify primary residence exclusion eligibility and timing requirements
□ Calculate depreciation recapture if applicable
□ Model both December and January closing scenarios with actual dollar amounts
□ Consult with tax professional to confirm your analysis
□ Communicate timing decision to all parties by December 20th
The Bottom Line: Your Money, Your Choice
This decision isn't about complex tax strategies or exotic loopholes. It's about basic math applied strategically. The difference between closing December 30th versus January 2nd can easily be $15,000-$50,000+ depending on your situation.
Here's what I know after 20+ years in real estate: The clients who take tax timing seriously build significantly more wealth over time. The ones who say "it's just a few days difference" often pay for that attitude for years.
After December 31st, the choice is made for you.
Don't leave $50,000 on the table because you didn't run the numbers.
Need help modeling your specific situation? Let's run through your scenarios together. The 30 minutes we spend now could save you more money than you'll make in the next six months. Also consult with your tax professional to confirm before making a decision.
Ready to make the right decision? Contact me today.
Please help support this newsletter by simply clicking on the advertising link below and making sure you are subscribed to the newsletter. This is at no cost to you but helps offset the cost of bringing this information to you for FREE!
The Briefing Leaders Rely On.
In a landscape flooded with hype and surface-level reporting, The Daily Upside delivers what business leaders actually need: clear, concise, and actionable intelligence on markets, strategy, and business innovation.
Founded by former bankers and veteran business journalists, it's built for decision-makers — not spectators. From macroeconomic shifts to sector-specific trends, The Daily Upside helps executives stay ahead of what’s shaping their industries.
That’s why over 1 million readers, including C-suite executives and senior decision-makers, start their day with it.
No noise. No jargon. Just business insight that drives results.
Book Shelf from Brett Vogeler: amazon.com/author/bvogeler
Need a roadmap? Reply in the comments section or send us an email for assistance. 360 Perspective Partners offers Professional Licensed Business, Commercial and Investment Brokerage Services along with providing Professional Licensed Community Management Services in Central Florida: https://my360perspective.com/
Contact me directly at [email protected]. To see our other useful Newsletters on this topic and others: https://realestate-business-broker-guru.beehiiv.com/
Stay ahead of the curve. Forward this to a colleague who needs to ride the wave and be sure to SUBSCRIBE for continued real estate and business content.