In partnership with
Last month, I watched sophisticated investors lose $2.1 million on what looked like a slam-dunk multifamily acquisition. These weren't rookies—they had decades of experience and access to top-tier advisors. The property had strong occupancy, solid rental history, and a cap rate that made everyone smile.
So what went wrong? They trusted the seller's financial statements.
Here's the uncomfortable truth: Seller-provided financials are marketing documents, not financial statements. They're designed to make properties look more profitable than they actually are. The most expensive mistakes aren't hidden in fine print—they're sitting right there in the operating expenses, disguised as "conservative projections" that are anything but conservative.
The 5 Critical Adjustments That Separate Winners from Losers
1. Management Expenses: The "Free" Cost That Isn't
Even if you plan to self-manage, always include 4-5% of gross rental income for management fees in your NOI calculation. Why? Because proper valuation requires analyzing the property as if professionally managed. On a property generating $2.4 million annually, that's $96,000-$120,000 you're probably not accounting for. Miss this line item, and you've artificially inflated your NOI by nearly $100,000—making a mediocre deal look exceptional. All appraisers and lenders include this in their analysis. You should as well.
2. Replacement Reserves: The $60,000 Reality Check
Professional underwriters set aside $250-$400 per unit annually for unexpected capital needs that affect your NOI. For a typical 150-unit property, that means $37,500-$60,000 should come off your bottom line every year. This isn't the same as planned CapEx—these are funds for the HVAC system that dies unexpectedly or the roof leak that can't wait for next year's budget.
3. Property Tax Reassessment: The 450% Shock
Most investors use the seller's current property taxes, but here's reality: taxes typically reset upon sale to reflect your purchase price. I recently analyzed a commercial property that experienced a 450% tax increase when it sold for $8 million after being assessed at $2 million. Always calculate property taxes based on what you're paying, not what the seller has been paying.
4. Insurance: Why Seller Numbers Are Worthless
Commercial insurance has increased 15-25% annually, especially in catastrophe-prone areas. Get your own quotes during due diligence—don't wait until closing. That $50,000 annual premium the seller shows you could easily become $75,000-$85,000 when you're the owner, due to updated risk assessments and current market rates.
5. Conservative NOI: The $12 Million Reality Gap
When you properly adjust for all the above factors, the numbers tell a very different story. Every dollar you miss in annual expenses reduces property value by $12-$20 (depending on your cap rate). The multiplication effect through capitalization rates means small oversights become massive overvaluations.
Real-World Impact: I recently reviewed a deal where the seller's pro forma showed $1.76 million NOI, implying a $29.3 million value at a 6% cap rate. After proper conservative underwriting—including all five adjustments above—the realistic NOI was $1.1 million, making the true value $18.3 million. The seller was asking $30 million for a property worth $18 million. That's a $12 million overvaluation that would have been catastrophic.
The Bottom Line
The difference between successful and failed real estate investments often comes down to financial due diligence discipline. If the deal only works with optimistic assumptions, it doesn't work at all. Your underwriting should be conservative enough that you walk away from 80% of the deals you analyze. When you find that rare property that still works under your most pessimistic scenarios, you've found a real opportunity.
Remember: Every missed expense doesn't just reduce your NOI—it multiplies through the cap rate to dramatically impact valuation. On typical commercial properties, overlooking $100,000 in annual expenses results in a $1.5-$2 million overvaluation. The most expensive lesson in real estate isn't learning what to look for—it's learning what you missed after closing.
Coming Next Week: Deep Dives into Each Critical Adjustment
Over the next five days, I'll be publishing detailed articles breaking down each of these critical adjustments:
"The Management Fee Blind Spot: Why Self-Managing Doesn't Mean Free" - The hidden costs of self-management and why professional valuation always includes management fees
"Capital Reserves vs. CapEx: The $60,000 Annual Line Item You're Missing" - Understanding the difference and properly budgeting for both
"Property Tax Reality: Preparing for the Post-Sale Shock" - How reassessment works and calculating your true tax burden
"Insurance Due Diligence: Why Seller Numbers Will Cost You Thousands" - Getting accurate insurance quotes and understanding coverage gaps
"Building Bulletproof NOI: The Conservative Underwriting Framework" - A step-by-step process for realistic financial modeling
Each article will include specific checklists, industry benchmarks, and real case studies to help you avoid the expensive mistakes that even experienced investors make.
Brett Vogeler, Real Estate Broker
Helping investors make smarter decisions through disciplined due diligence
Please help support this newsletter by simply clicking on the advertising link below and making sure you are subscribed to the newsletter. This is at no cost to you but helps offset the cost of bringing this information to you for FREE!
Introducing the first AI-native CRM
Connect your email, and you’ll instantly get a CRM with enriched customer insights and a platform that grows with your business.
With AI at the core, Attio lets you:
Prospect and route leads with research agents
Get real-time insights during customer calls
Build powerful automations for your complex workflows
Join industry leaders like Granola, Taskrabbit, Flatfile and more.
Book Shelf from Brett Vogeler: amazon.com/author/bvogeler
Need a roadmap? Reply in the comments section or send us an email for assistance. 360 Perspective Partners offers Professional Licensed Business, Commercial and Investment Brokerage Services along with providing Professional Licensed Community Management Services in Central Florida: https://my360perspective.com/
Contact me directly at [email protected]. To see our other useful Newsletters on this topic and others: https://realestate-business-broker-guru.beehiiv.com/
Stay ahead of the curve. Forward this to a colleague who needs to ride the wave and be sure to SUBSCRIBE for continued real estate and business content.