Let me start with a number that should get your attention: 67.5%.
That's the percentage of North American private equity deals that now include rollover equity—up from 56.4% just three years ago. In the lower-middle market where most of us operate ($5M-$50M enterprise value), the trend is even more pronounced.
Translation: Two out of every three deals you touch will involve rollover equity in some form. Yet most business brokers still treat it as an exotic exception rather than the new normal.
Here's the reality: clients are already hearing about rollover equity from buyers. They're getting term sheets with confusing language about "retained equity," "minority rolls," and "second bites of the apple." They're wondering if they're being taken advantage of—or if they're missing an opportunity.
The broker who can confidently guide them through this complexity wins the engagement. The one who can't loses to a more sophisticated advisor.
This isn't just about understanding a deal structure. It's about positioning yourself as the strategic advisor clients can't afford to work without in a market that's fundamentally changed.
Let me show you how.
Why Rollover Equity Should Matter to You (Beyond Just Closing Deals)
Before we dive into tactics, let's talk about why mastering rollover equity is worth your time and attention.
1. You'll Command Higher Fees
Complex deal structures justify premium pricing. Brokers who coordinate rollover transactions—managing tax attorneys, transaction counsel, financial advisors, and navigating intricate negotiations—can command 1-2% fee premiums over standard engagements.
Why? Because you're not just finding a buyer and shepherding documents. You're architecting a multi-year partnership and protecting your client from sophisticated buyers who do this for a living.
2. You'll Differentiate from Competition
Most brokers in the $5M-$25M space are still operating with 1990s playbooks: CIM, buyer outreach, LOI, due diligence, close. That works—until your client gets a PE offer with 20% rollover and turns to you asking, "What do you think? Is this fair?"
If you can't answer confidently, they'll find someone who can. Your rollover expertise becomes your competitive moat.
3. You'll Build Relationships with PE Firms
Private equity firms are sitting on $2+ trillion in dry powder and need to deploy it. The lower-middle market is increasingly their target. PE firms value brokers who:
Understand their structures and motivations
Pre-qualify sellers for rollover appetite
Present realistic deal structures upfront
Don't waste their time on sellers who'll never accept minority positions
Become that broker, and you'll get repeat deal flow from multiple PE shops. One good PE relationship can feed your pipeline for years.
4. You'll Protect Your Clients (and Your Reputation)
Here's the uncomfortable truth: rollover equity deals that go bad can be catastrophic for sellers. I've seen owners lose $3M-$5M in rolled equity when deals went sideways—bad buyer, flawed strategy, excessive debt, misaligned interests.
Your job is to prevent those outcomes. When you do, you build a reputation as the broker who "really looks out for sellers." That's worth more than any marketing campaign.
The Rollover Equity Client Qualification Framework
Not every seller is a candidate for rollover equity. In fact, pushing rollover on the wrong client is professional malpractice—it creates misalignment, deal failure, and potential liability.
Here's the systematic framework I use to assess "Rollover Readiness" in initial consultations:
The Five-Factor Assessment
Score each factor 1-10 (1 = poor fit, 10 = excellent fit):
Factor 1: Liquidity Requirements
What you're assessing: Does the seller need 100% cash, or can they handle 20-30% being illiquid for 5-7 years?
Questions to ask:
"What's the minimum cash you need at closing to accomplish your personal financial goals?"
"Do you have other liquid assets, or is this business sale your primary nest egg?"
"What happens if 20% of the sale proceeds is locked up for seven years?"
"Are there immediate needs—debt payoff, estate planning, healthcare—that require full liquidity?"
Scoring guide:
8-10: Seller needs <75% liquidity; has diversified assets; views rollover as "risk capital"
5-7: Seller wants 80-85% liquidity; tight but manageable; some concern about illiquidity
1-4: Seller needs 90%+ cash; no other assets; liquidity-driven exit (retirement, health, divorce)
Red flags:
"I'm counting on this money to retire"
"I need to pay off personal guarantees on business debt"
"My spouse wants nothing to do with this business anymore"
Factor 2: Risk Tolerance
What you're assessing: Can the seller emotionally handle being a minority shareholder with limited control and potential for total loss?
Questions to ask:
"How do you feel about being a 20% minority owner versus 100% owner?"
"Can you handle watching someone else make decisions you disagree with?"
"On a scale of 1-10, how comfortable are you with equity risk—where you could lose the entire rollover amount?"
"How did you react during the 2008 financial crisis or COVID? Did you panic or stay the course?"
Scoring guide:
8-10: Entrepreneurial risk-taker; comfortable with volatility; understands equity investing; has lost money before and learned from it
5-7: Moderate risk tolerance; nervous but rational; needs education and reassurance
1-4: Risk-averse; sleeps poorly with uncertainty; prefers guaranteed outcomes; never invested in equities
Red flags:
"I want my money safe and accessible"
"I've worked too hard to gamble now"
Extreme emotional reactions to market volatility discussions
Factor 3: Business Growth Potential
What you're assessing: Does the business have credible pathways to 2-3x value creation that would make a "second bite" worthwhile?
Questions to ask yourself (due diligence):
Is this a fragmented industry where roll-up strategies work?
Are there obvious expansion opportunities (geography, products, customers)?
Is the business scale-dependent (benefits from getting bigger)?
Are margins compressible (room for operational improvement)?
Is technology/digital transformation applicable?
Scoring guide:
8-10: Clear consolidation play; proven roll-up model in industry; obvious operational improvements; large TAM
5-7: Moderate growth potential; requires execution but plausible; some operational leverage
1-4: Mature/declining market; limited growth vectors; margin pressures; technology disruption risk
Red flags:
Declining revenue trend (3+ years)
Customer concentration >30% top 3 customers
Regulatory headwinds or litigation exposure
Technology disruption imminent
Factor 4: Seller Involvement Appetite
What you're assessing: Is the seller willing/able to stay involved for 2-3 years post-closing, or do they want a clean exit?
Questions to ask:
"What does life look like for you 12 months after closing? Three years?"
"Would you be comfortable staying on in a consulting or advisory capacity?"
"How do you feel about reporting to new management?"
"Are you energized by the business's future, or are you just done?"
Scoring guide:
8-10: Wants to stay involved; energized about growth phase; willing to be minority partner; not ready for full retirement
5-7: Open to transitional role; 12-24 months okay; wants reduced responsibility but not immediate exit
1-4: Burned out; health issues; wants complete exit; "done with this industry"
Red flags:
"I'm exhausted and ready to move on"
"I want nothing to do with this business after closing"
Health issues or relocation plans
Spouse insisting on retirement
Factor 5: Sophistication & Advisory Team
What you're assessing: Does the seller have the sophistication and professional support to navigate complex negotiations?
Questions to ask:
"Do you have a transaction attorney and CPA experienced in business sales?"
"Have you been involved in previous M&A transactions?"
"How comfortable are you reading operating agreements and understanding equity structures?"
"Do you have a financial advisor helping with post-sale wealth planning?"
Scoring guide:
8-10: Previous M&A experience; established relationships with transaction attorney/CPA; financially sophisticated; asks smart questions
5-7: Some sophistication; willing to engage advisors; coachable; asks for help when needed
1-4: No advisory team; resistant to professional fees; expects broker to handle everything; unsophisticated about equity
Red flags:
"I can't afford attorneys—that's what I'm paying you for"
Unrealistic expectations about process
Unwilling to invest in proper advisors
The Rollover Readiness Score
Add up the five factors (max score: 50)
40-50 points: Excellent rollover candidate. Actively market to PE firms; emphasize rollover flexibility in positioning
30-39 points: Good candidate with education. Present rollover as option; provide thorough education on pros/cons
20-29 points: Marginal candidate. Consider rollover only if it materially improves valuation or deal certainty
Below 20: Poor candidate. Focus on all-cash or seller-financed structures; don't force rollover
Critical rule: Never proceed with rollover below 25 points without extensive client education and written acknowledgment of risks.
How to Position Rollover Equity in Marketing (Without Scaring Away Buyers or Sellers)
One of the biggest mistakes brokers make is being too explicit about rollover in marketing materials. Here's the right approach:
In the CIM (Confidential Information Memorandum)
❌ Don't say:
"Seller requires 20% equity rollover"
"Seller will only consider offers with rollover component"
"Seller demands continued ownership"
✅ Do say:
"Ownership is open to continued participation in the business's growth trajectory"
"Flexible transaction structure to align with the right strategic partner"
"Seller interested in partnership opportunities with value-creation focus"
Why this matters: You want buyers to propose rollover structures based on their preferences, not react to seller demands. This gives you negotiating leverage.
In Buyer Conversations
Early-stage discussions (pre-LOI):
"My client has built something special and is open to staying involved with the right partner. What's your typical approach to management rollover?"
This accomplishes three things:
Signals seller openness without commitment
Lets you assess buyer's rollover expectations
Positions seller as valuable partner, not desperate seller
During LOI negotiations:
"We have multiple interested parties. The one that wins will demonstrate strong value creation thesis and fair partnership terms. Walk me through your rollover structure."
This frames rollover as competitive differentiator for buyers, not seller concession.
Negotiation Tactics: Getting the Best Terms for Your Clients
Assuming you've qualified the client and received offers with rollover provisions, here's how to negotiate terms that actually protect sellers:
Tactic 1: The "Show Me Your Plan" Strategy
Before accepting any rollover, demand the buyer's detailed value creation thesis:
What to request:
100-day plan (specific initiatives and owners)
3-year financial projections (revenue, EBITDA, cash flow)
Org chart evolution (who gets hired/fired when)
Capital investment plans (how much, when, for what)
Comparable transaction track record (their last 3 deals in this space)
Your positioning: "My client is betting $2-3M on your ability to execute. We need to understand exactly how you're planning to grow this business before we commit capital."
What you're really doing:
Separating sophisticated buyers from tire-kickers
Identifying flawed strategies before signing
Creating negotiating leverage ("Your plan seems optimistic—we'd need better terms to take that risk")
Red flags:
Vague answers about "operational improvements"
No written plan or projections
Can't articulate specific value creation levers
Track record of failed deals in industry
Tactic 2: The "Preferred Terms" Trade
When buyers push for higher rollover percentages, trade up to better equity terms:
Standard PE request: "We'd like the seller to roll 25% in common equity."
Your counter: "We're open to 25%, but at that level, we need preferred equity with 1.5x liquidation preference and anti-dilution protection."
Translation: Seller gets paid back their $2.5M rollover at 1.5x ($3.75M) before common equity splits proceeds. This downside protection is worth accepting higher rollover percentage.
Negotiating framework:
Rollover % | Equity Type | Additional Protections |
|---|---|---|
10-15% | Common equity | Information rights, quarterly financials |
15-20% | Common equity | + Board observer seat |
20-25% | Preferred equity | + 1.25x liquidation preference |
25-30% | Preferred equity | + 1.5x liquidation preference + anti-dilution |
30%+ | Preferred equity | + 2.0x liquidation preference + board seat + put option |
Your message to buyers: "We're flexible on rollover percentage, but the terms must reflect the risk level."
Tactic 3: The "Sunset Clause" Protection
The biggest fear sellers have: permanent illiquidity with no exit path. Address it upfront:
What to negotiate: "Seller receives put option exercisable after 7 years, requiring company to purchase shares at fair market value as determined by independent appraisal."
Why 7 years?
Aligns with typical PE holding period (median 6.5 years)
Gives buyer reasonable time to execute growth plan
Provides seller with guaranteed exit mechanism
Alternative structure: "Seller's put option becomes exercisable upon: (a) 7 years from closing, or (b) termination without cause, or (c) change in control, whichever occurs first."
This prevents scenarios where buyer:
Holds indefinitely to delay seller payout
Forces seller out then withholds liquidity
Sells company but tries to roll seller's equity again
Many PE firms will resist this. Your response: "We're committing $3M for potentially a decade. We need a backstop. If you're confident in your 5-7 year exit plan, this shouldn't be an issue."
Tactic 4: The "Debt Covenant" Shield
Remember the horror story where seller's rollover got wiped out by excessive debt? Prevent it:
What to negotiate: "Company may not incur additional debt beyond 4.0x EBITDA without majority equity holder approval, except for working capital lines not exceeding $XXX."
Why this matters: PE firms love "dividend recapitalizations"—taking on new debt to pay themselves dividends, which:
Increases company risk
Reduces enterprise value
Makes seller's equity subordinate to more debt
Can wipe out common equity in downside scenarios
Your framing: "We're aligned on growth capital, but we need protection against financial engineering that shifts risk to minority holders."
If buyer refuses: Major red flag. They're planning aggressive leverage strategies that put seller's rollover at risk.
Tactic 5: The "Information Rights" Transparency
Minority shareholders are often kept in the dark. Prevent it:
What to negotiate:
Quarterly financial statements (P&L, balance sheet, cash flow) within 30 days of quarter end
Annual audited financials within 90 days of year end
Annual operating plan presented 30 days before fiscal year
Notice of material events within 10 days (acquisitions, debt raises, management changes)
Board observer rights (attend board meetings, receive materials)
Why this matters: Knowledge is power. If you see problems early (declining margins, customer losses, cash burn), you can:
Engage management to correct course
Document issues for potential disputes
Prepare for downside scenarios
Make informed decisions about any liquidity opportunities
Many buyers offer minimal information rights. Push back: "You're asking my client to be a long-term partner. Partners don't operate in the dark. These are standard minority shareholder protections."
The LOI Checklist: 15 Rollover Terms That Must Be Addressed
Many brokers let critical rollover terms slip to "definitive agreement" phase, where client has less leverage. Lock down these terms in the LOI:
Economic Terms
□ 1. Total purchase price (enterprise value clearly stated)
□ 2. Cash portion (dollar amount at closing)
□ 3. Rollover portion (dollar amount and % ownership)
□ 4. Calculation basis (pro rata or fully diluted)
□ 5. Equity value vs. enterprise value (treatment of debt/cash)
Equity Structure
□ 6. Type of equity (common, preferred, voting/non-voting)
□ 7. Same class as buyer? (pari passu with PE firm's equity)
□ 8. Liquidation preference (if preferred equity)
□ 9. Anti-dilution protection (weighted average or full ratchet)
Governance & Control
□ 10. Board representation (seat, observer, or neither)
□ 11. Information rights (financial reporting frequency)
□ 12. Protective provisions (veto rights on major decisions)
□ 13. Related party transaction approval (prevents self-dealing)
Exit & Liquidity
□ 14. Tag-along rights (seller can participate in any sale)
□ 15. Put option timeline (seller can force buyback after X years)
Pro tip: Use this as a literal checklist during LOI review. If a term isn't addressed, note it as "To be negotiated in definitive agreement, but general principles are: [insert your desired terms]."
How to Build Your Rollover Equity Practice (90-Day Action Plan)
Knowing this stuff is one thing. Building a reputation as the go-to broker for PE-backed deals is another. Here's your roadmap:
Month 1: Education & Relationships
Week 1-2: Deep Learning
Review this research again (yes, again)
Read 5 recent PE deal announcements in your target industries
Join ACG (Association for Corporate Growth) in your region
Attend one M&A or PE networking event
Week 3-4: Build Your Network
Schedule lunch with 3 PE firms active in lower-middle market
Ask: "What's your typical rollover structure? What makes sellers good partners?"
Connect with 2 transaction attorneys who specialize in PE deals
Find a CPA firm with M&A tax expertise (Section 721/351)
Deliverable: Professional network of 3 PE firms, 2 attorneys, 1 CPA firm
Month 2: Marketing & Positioning
Week 1-2: Content Creation
Write LinkedIn article: "Rollover Equity: What Business Owners Need to Know"
Create 2-page client handout: "Is Rollover Equity Right for Your Business Sale?"
Update your website bio to mention "PE-backed transaction expertise"
Add rollover equity case study to your materials (anonymized)
Week 3-4: Outreach & Education
Offer to present to local business owner forum: "Current M&A Trends"
Host webinar: "Private Equity 101 for Business Owners"
Write article for local business journal
Guest on business podcast discussing exit strategies
Deliverable: Positioned as thought leader on PE/rollover equity in your market
Month 3: Client Application
Week 1-2: Pipeline Assessment
Review current pipeline: which clients are rollover candidates?
Score each using the 5-Factor Framework
Schedule "exit strategy review" calls with 8+ rated clients
Present rollover as option with education materials
Week 3-4: Buyer Targeting
Create "PE-friendly" deal package for rollover candidates
Proactively reach out to PE firms with specific opportunities
Emphasize seller's rollover flexibility in conversations
Request feedback: "What would make this more attractive?"
Deliverable: 2-3 engagements actively marketed to PE firms with rollover positioning
Competitive Positioning: What to Say (and Not Say)
When competing against other brokers, rollover expertise is your differentiator. Here's how to articulate it:
In Pitch Meetings
❌ Weak positioning: "I can help you sell your business. I have lots of buyer relationships."
✅ Strong positioning: "I specialize in complex transactions involving private equity and sophisticated buyers. About 70% of PE deals now include rollover equity provisions—structures where you keep 15-25% ownership and get a 'second bite of the apple.' I've guided clients through these negotiations, ensuring they understand the tax implications, governance protections, and wealth-building potential. Most brokers don't understand these structures; I make them work for sellers."
In Objection Handling
Client: "Another broker said they'd charge 1% less commission."
Your response: "I understand fee sensitivity. Here's the difference: when you get a PE offer with rollover equity, you'll have millions of dollars in a complex minority shareholder position. The broker who saves you 1% today but can't protect you in those negotiations could cost you your entire rollover—$2M, $3M, or more. I coordinate your tax attorney, transaction counsel, and financial advisors to ensure your interests are protected. That's worth the difference."
Three Real Conversations You'll Have (And How to Handle Them)
Conversation 1: The Skeptical Seller
Client: "The buyer is asking me to roll 20%. I feel like they're trying to pay me less."
Your response: "Let's look at the total economics. They're offering $10M total value: $8M cash plus $2M rollover. That's actually $500K higher than the all-cash offer from the strategic buyer at $9.5M.
But here's what matters more: if they execute their plan and grow EBITDA from $2M to $5M, then exit at 12x, that's a $60M sale. Your 20% becomes $12M. Combined with the $8M cash, you'd have $20M total—double the all-cash deal.
Now, there's risk. If the business declines, you could lose the $2M. So the question is: do you believe in their growth plan? And if you do, are the terms structured to protect you as a minority shareholder?
Let me show you what protections we need to negotiate..."
Conversation 2: The PE Firm Pushing Back
PE Partner: "Our standard deal structure is 25% common equity rollover. That's what we do."
Your response: "I appreciate that you have standard structures. Our client is absolutely willing to roll equity—in fact, they're excited about partnering with you. But we need to ensure the terms reflect the risk-reward balance.
At 25% rollover, we're talking about $3M+ of my client's capital being illiquid for 5-7 years with no control. We'd need one of three things to make that work:
Option A: Preferred equity with 1.5x liquidation preference
Option B: Board seat plus put option after 7 years
Option C: Reduce rollover to 15% with common equity
Which of those works best with your structure? We're trying to find the alignment point."
Conversation 3: The Attorney Who Disagrees
Client's attorney: "I don't like this rollover provision. Too risky. I recommend the all-cash offer."
Your response to client (after the call): "Your attorney's job is to flag risks—and they're right to point them out. Rollover equity is risky.
But here's what I want you to consider: your attorney is evaluating legal risk. I'm helping you evaluate economic opportunity. Those are different lenses.
The all-cash deal is $9.5M, nets you ~$7M after taxes.
The rollover deal is $8M cash ($6.4M after taxes) plus $2M equity that could be worth $6M-$8M at a future sale. Even if the rollover only returns 50% ($1M), you're still ahead.
What I suggest: let's have your attorney negotiate the strongest possible protective provisions—board observer rights, debt covenants, put options—so we get the upside with downside protection.
Your attorney's concerns are valid. Let's address them with better terms, not by walking away from potential upside."
The Hard Truth About Rollover Equity Deals
Let me close with some brutal honesty:
Not every rollover deal works out. I've seen situations where:
Buyers executed poorly and sellers lost millions
Strategic disagreements poisoned relationships
Economic downturns crushed valuations
Debt loads wiped out common equity
But I've also seen:
Sellers double and triple their transaction value
Owners build meaningful second-chapter wealth
Partnerships that exceeded both parties' expectations
Clean exits when put options were exercised fairly
The difference isn't luck—it's diligence, negotiation, and structure.
Your job as a broker is not to be a cheerleader for rollover equity. It's to be a clear-eyed advisor who:
Assesses client suitability honestly
Educates on real risks and rewards
Negotiates protective terms aggressively
Coordinates professional advisors effectively
Positions clients for long-term success
When you do that well, you become irreplaceable.
The Bottom Line
Rollover equity is not a passing trend. It's the new normal in the lower-middle market, driven by $2+ trillion in PE dry powder, higher interest rates, and the need for capital-efficient deal structures.
The brokers who thrive over the next 5 years will be those who embrace this complexity rather than avoid it. Who educate rather than confuse. Who protect clients rather than just close deals.
Your competitors are hoping this trend passes. You're going to master it instead.
That's your competitive advantage.
Brett Vogeler is an author, business broker, real estate broker, and entrepreneur specializing in complex M&A transactions. He has guided numerous clients through private equity-backed sales and rollover equity negotiations in the lower-middle market.
Want to discuss specific rollover situations in your pipeline? Let's connect.
Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice. Business brokers should work closely with qualified transaction attorneys and CPAs when structuring rollover equity deals. Always ensure clients receive appropriate professional counsel before making transaction decisions.
Please help support this newsletter by simply clicking on the advertising link below and making sure you are subscribed to the newsletter. This is at no cost to you but helps offset the cost of bringing this information to you for FREE!
Last Time the Market Was This Expensive, Investors Waited 14 Years to Break Even
In 1999, the S&P 500 peaked. Then it took 14 years to gradually recover by 2013.
Today? Goldman Sachs sounds crazy forecasting 3% returns for 2024 to 2034.
But we’re currently seeing the highest price for the S&P 500 compared to earnings since the dot-com boom.
So, maybe that’s why they’re not alone; Vanguard projects about 5%.
In fact, now just about everything seems priced near all time highs. Equities, gold, crypto, etc.
But billionaires have long diversified a slice of their portfolios with one asset class that is poised to rebound.
It’s post war and contemporary art.
Sounds crazy, but over 70,000 investors have followed suit since 2019—with Masterworks.
You can invest in shares of artworks featuring Banksy, Basquiat, Picasso, and more.
24 exits later, results speak for themselves: net annualized returns like 14.6%, 17.6%, and 17.8%.*
My subscribers can skip the waitlist.
*Investing involves risk. Past performance is not indicative of future returns. Important Reg A disclosures: masterworks.com/cd.
Book Shelf from Brett Vogeler: amazon.com/author/bvogeler
Need a roadmap? Reply in the comments section or send us an email for assistance. 360 Perspective Partners offers Professional Licensed Business, Commercial and Investment Brokerage Services along with providing Professional Licensed Community Management Services in Central Florida: https://my360perspective.com/
Contact me directly at [email protected]. To see our other useful Newsletters on this topic and others: https://realestate-business-broker-guru.beehiiv.com/
Stay ahead of the curve. Forward this to a colleague who needs to ride the wave and be sure to SUBSCRIBE for continued real estate and business content.