Sponsored by
Your Business Sold for Millions. So Why Doesn’t It Feel Like Millions?
The headline sale price is not your payday. Broker fees, legal costs, taxes, debt payoff, working-capital adjustments, escrows, and earnouts all stand between the deal price and the cash you actually keep.
When owners start thinking about selling, they usually fixate on the headline number. “If I can get $3 million,” or “If I can get $10 million,” they tell themselves, “I’m in great shape.” But the price on the letter of intent is not the same thing as the money that lands in your bank account. The real question is not what your business sells for. The real question is what you actually keep after broker fees, legal and accounting bills, debt payoff, taxes, escrows, working-capital adjustments, and any portion of the deal tied up in an earnout.
That distinction matters more than most owners realize. A deal can look terrific on paper and still leave you disappointed at closing. Why? Because buyers generally value a company on an enterprise basis, while sellers live on equity value. Harney Capital puts it plainly: in many deals, the buyer is paying for the operating value of the business, not for the seller’s cash, and not for the seller’s debt. Which means your sale proceeds are often reduced by debt, adjusted for working capital, and then reduced again by transaction costs before you ever see a wire hit your account.
Here is the straight-shooting version of the formula:
Headline Price
minus Debt Payoff
minus Broker Fee
minus Legal and Accounting Costs
plus or minus Working Capital Adjustment
minus Escrows or Holdbacks
minus Taxes due now
equals what you may actually control after closing
And even that may overstate what you “walk away with,” because part of your purchase price may be tied to future performance instead of paid in cash on day one.
Let’s start with broker fees, because they are visible and easy to understand. MidStreet says Main Street businesses often pay around 8% to 10% of the sale price, with 10% being common. For larger lower-middle-market deals, many firms use a Double Lehman formula or flat percentage. On a $10 million sale, MidStreet illustrates a $400,000 success fee under both a Double Lehman-style approach and a 4% flat fee. That is a meaningful amount of money, but it is also only one line item in a much bigger net-proceeds picture.
Then come the professional fees. Varnum Law notes that a seller’s transaction expenses often include broker fees, attorney fees, accountant fees, title insurance, and related deal costs. Those expenses are not theoretical. They come straight out of the purchase price. In other words, if you are mentally spending your gross sale number before the deal closes, you are spending money that may never be yours.
Now let’s talk about the item that catches many owners off guard: debt payoff. If your business has bank loans, lines of credit, equipment notes, tax liabilities, capital leases, shareholder loans, or other debt-like obligations, those usually have to be cleared at or through closing. Harney Capital explains that most middle-market deals are structured on a “cash-free, debt-free” basis, which means sellers typically use sale proceeds to settle those obligations first and keep what remains. Their example is simple and powerful: a $20 million purchase price with $5 million of net debt leaves $15 million to the seller before transaction costs and other adjustments. That is a big difference.
And the surprises do not stop there. Working-capital adjustments can shrink your proceeds at the eleventh hour. Varnum warns that if the business delivers less net working capital at closing than the agreed target, the purchase price can be reduced dollar for dollar. Harney makes the same point: enterprise value gets bridged to equity value through debt, cash, and working-capital math. Sellers who ignore that bridge often feel blindsided even when the buyer is following the contract exactly.
Then there are earnouts, which deserve special attention because they distort what many owners think they are being paid. Morgan & Westfield defines an earnout as deferred consideration paid only if the business hits certain targets after closing, such as revenue or EBITDA milestones. That means an earnout is not closing-day money. It is contingent money. Maybe you receive it later. Maybe you do not. Earnouts are often used to bridge valuation gaps, but they also create risk for sellers because the buyer usually controls the business after closing. If the buyer changes spending, staffing, pricing, or strategy, your earnout can evaporate.
So if part of your deal is in an earnout, ask yourself a hard question: Is this truly sale proceeds, or is it just hoped-for future proceeds? Sellers often count the full purchase price in their heads, then discover too late that only a portion arrives at closing, another portion is held in escrow, and a final portion depends on post-sale performance they no longer control. That is how a business owner sells for a “great number” and still feels cash-poor on closing day.
Taxes are another major divider between price and reality. The IRS says the sale of a business is generally treated as the sale of individual assets, not one single asset, and the tax treatment can vary depending on what is being sold. Inventory may produce ordinary income. Depreciable assets may trigger depreciation recapture. Goodwill may receive more favorable capital-gain treatment. The structure of the deal and the purchase price allocation can materially change what you owe. PKF O’Connor Davies notes that sellers generally prefer more allocation to goodwill and less to categories that create ordinary income, because the difference between capital-gains treatment and ordinary-income treatment can be substantial.
And federal taxes may only be part of the pain. California’s Franchise Tax Board states clearly that California does not provide a lower capital-gains rate, which means state tax can further reduce the proceeds you expected to keep. For owners in high-tax states, the gap between gross price and spendable net proceeds can become uncomfortably wide.
That is why smart sellers stop asking, “What is my business worth?” and start asking, “What will I net after all costs, taxes, and deal mechanics?” Fiduciary Trust makes an important point here: owners need to know whether net after-tax sale proceeds, combined with other assets, will actually support the life they want next. If not, it may make sense to improve the business, wait for a stronger market, pay down debt, or negotiate a better structure before selling. Selling is not just a liquidity event. It is a life-planning event.
That last point may be the most important one in this entire article. Plenty of owners assume the sale proceeds will be “more than enough,” only to learn that their business had been funding a lifestyle that is hard to replace. Fiduciary Trust warns that owners need a real financial plan, not a guess, and that they should stress-test whether the proceeds will support future living expenses, healthcare, travel, housing, family support, and the life they want after the closing celebration ends.
So what should you do now, before you ever sign a letter of intent?
First, get brutally honest about your likely net proceeds, not just your hoped-for sale price. Second, understand that debt and working capital can materially change the wire amount on closing day. Third, treat earnouts as uncertain upside, not guaranteed cash. Fourth, plan for taxes early, because by the time the deal is heavily negotiated, many of your best tax-planning options may be gone. And fifth, work with the right people: a business broker to drive value and terms, a CPA to model your after-tax outcome, and an attorney to protect you from post-closing surprises.
The bottom line is simple. You do not retire on enterprise value. You retire on net proceeds. And if you have not done the math on what you will actually walk away with, you are not ready to judge whether an offer is good, whether the timing is right, or whether the next chapter of your life is truly funded.
P.S. —Want a comprehensive tool for Building a Transferable Business? Check out my new book here: https://a.co/d/07iNhH3X. Have a question about valuations or selling your business? Reply to this email. I read every response, and your question might shape a future article in this series.
Please help support this newsletter by simply clicking on the advertising link below and making sure you are subscribed to the newsletter. This is at no cost to you but helps offset the cost of bringing this information to you for FREE!
What Will Your Retirement Look Like?
Retirement looks different for everyone. What it costs, where the income comes from, how long it needs to last. Those answers are specific to you.
The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income helps investors with $1,000,000 or more work through the questions that matter and build a plan around the answers.
Download your free guide to start turning a savings number into an actual retirement income strategy.
Book Shelf from Brett Vogeler: amazon.com/author/bvogeler
Need a roadmap? Reply in the comments section or send us an email for assistance. 360 Perspective Partners offers Professional Licensed Business, Commercial and Investment Brokerage Services along with providing Professional Licensed Community Management Services in Central Florida: https://my360perspective.com/
Contact me directly at [email protected]. To see our other useful Newsletters on this topic and others: https://realestate-business-broker-guru.beehiiv.com/
Stay ahead of the curve. Forward this to a colleague who needs to ride the wave and be sure to SUBSCRIBE for continued real estate and business content.