Day 4: The Growth Engines - Stocks & Commodities

In 1930, as the stock market crashed and investors panicked, John D. Rockefeller Jr. quietly accumulated shares in some of America's greatest companies at fire-sale prices. While others fled stocks entirely, he understood a fundamental truth: great businesses bought at terrible prices create generational wealth.

But here's what made Rockefeller's approach different from modern stock investing: he didn't just buy stocks—he bought pieces of businesses he understood, in industries he could influence, for time horizons measured in decades.

Historical Wealthy Families (1800s-1950s) Allocation:

Modern Family Office Allocation:

The shift is striking: modern families have increased stock allocations by 55% while reducing commodity exposure by 58%. This reflects both the evolution of financial markets and a fundamental change in how wealthy families view market-based investments.

The Rockefellers approached stock investing like business acquisition. When they bought shares in banks, railroads, or industrial companies, they often accumulated significant positions and took board seats. This wasn't passive investing—it was strategic control.

John D. Rockefeller's investments in banking (Chase National Bank), real estate (Rockefeller Center), and various industrial concerns were all approached with the same systematic analysis he applied to oil refining. He bought businesses, not ticker symbols.

Most importantly, the Rockefellers held these positions for decades. Their stock investments were generational plays, not trading positions.

The Rothschild family built much of their wealth through commodity trading and control. They didn't just trade gold—they controlled gold refineries, silver mines, and had exclusive relationships with major commodity producers worldwide.

Their approach to commodities was vertical integration: own the mines, control the transportation, dominate the trading, and influence the end markets. This provided both investment returns and strategic control over essential resources.

The Rothschilds understood that commodities weren't just investments—they were the building blocks of industrial civilization. Control the inputs, influence the outputs.

Historical wealthy families allocated heavily to commodities for reasons that remain relevant today:

Industrial Control: Commodity ownership provided influence over entire industries. Control oil, control transportation. Control metals, control manufacturing.

Inflation Protection: Physical commodities historically rise with general price levels, protecting purchasing power during inflationary periods.

Crisis Value: During wars and economic disruption, physical commodities retain value when financial assets may not.

Limited Supply: Unlike paper assets, physical commodities have finite supplies that cannot be printed or created artificially.

Today's 31% stock allocation by family offices reflects several modern advantages:

Market Accessibility: Modern stock markets provide liquidity and transparency that didn't exist historically. Buying and selling large positions is now routine.

Professional Management: The rise of professional fund management allows families to access diversified stock portfolios without direct involvement.

Regulatory Protection: Modern securities regulation provides investor protections that didn't exist in the early 20th century.

Global Diversification: Today's families can easily invest across international markets, reducing concentration risk.

Warren Buffett's investment philosophy mirrors historical wealthy family approaches more than modern portfolio theory. He buys pieces of businesses he understands, holds them for decades, and focuses on long-term competitive advantages.

Buffett's major holdings—Coca-Cola, Apple, American Express—are purchased with the intention of permanent ownership. This approach generated wealth comparable to historical family fortunes through patient, concentrated investing.

Modern families' reduced commodity allocation (5% vs. historical 12%) may represent a strategic error:

Financialization Bias: Modern wealth management focuses heavily on financial instruments rather than physical assets, potentially missing inflation protection.

Complexity Avoidance: Commodity investing requires specialized knowledge and storage arrangements that many families prefer to avoid.

Short-term Thinking: Commodities often require longer investment horizons than modern portfolio management typically employs.

Regulatory Obstacles: Modern regulations make direct commodity ownership more complex than in historical periods.

Historical crisis performance reveals the complementary nature of these asset classes:

Today's family offices face a dilemma historical families didn't encounter: financialized markets where everything moves together during crises.

Modern stock and commodity prices often correlate during major market dislocations, reducing the diversification benefits that historical families enjoyed. This suggests the need for more sophisticated approaches to both asset classes.

Historical wealthy families' stock strategies offer modern lessons:

Modern investors can apply historical commodity strategies through:

The Hunt brothers' attempt to corner the silver market in the 1970s demonstrates both the power and dangers of concentrated commodity investing. They successfully drove silver prices from $6 to over $50 per ounce, but their leverage and concentration ultimately led to spectacular failure.

The lesson: historical wealthy families succeeded through systematic, unleveraged commodity investments, not speculative corners or manipulations.

The most successful approach may combine historical wisdom with modern tools:

Quality Stock Selection: Focus on businesses with commodity-like characteristics—essential products, pricing power, and long-term demand growth.

Commodity Exposure: Maintain meaningful commodity allocation through physical ownership, commodity-focused stocks, or specialized funds.

Crisis Preparation: Use both stocks and commodities as complementary crisis hedges with different risk profiles.

Time Arbitrage: Take advantage of modern markets' short-term focus to invest with historical families' long-term perspective.

Educational Disclaimer: This content is for educational purposes only and should not be considered personalized investment advice. Stock and commodity investing involves significant risks including total loss of capital. Historical performance does not guarantee future results. Please consult with qualified investment professionals before making allocation decisions.

I'll reveal why I allocate only 5% to Stocks and 10% to Commodities—bucking modern trends in favor of historical wealth preservation principles.

Full allocation preview: Personal Residence 10% | Investment Real Estate 40% | Business Ownership 10% | Monetary Metals 23% | Cash 1% | Commodities 10% | Stocks 5% | Intellectual Properties 1%

As a Licensed Real Estate and Business Broker, I help clients build diversified portfolios that include both traditional and alternative investments aligned with their long-term wealth preservation goals. Tomorrow, we'll integrate everything into a comprehensive modern strategy.

Please help support this newsletter by simply clicking on the advertising link below and making sure you are subscribed to the newsletter. This is at no cost to you but helps offset the cost of bringing this information to you for FREE!

Markets move fast. Reading this makes you faster.

Every weekday, you’ll get a 5-minute Elite Trade Club newsletter covering the top stories, market-moving headlines, and the hottest stocks — delivered before the opening bell.

Whether you’re a casual trader or serious investor, it’s everything you need to know before making your next move. Join 160k+ other investors who get their market news the smart and simple way.

Click Here to Join Now

Book Shelf from Brett Vogeler: amazon.com/author/bvogeler

 Need a roadmap? Reply in the comments section or send us an email for assistance.  360 Perspective Partners offers Professional Licensed Business, Commercial and Investment Brokerage Services along with providing Professional Licensed Community Management Services in Central Florida: https://my360perspective.com/

Contact me directly at [email protected]. To see our other useful Newsletters on this topic and others: https://realestate-business-broker-guru.beehiiv.com/

Stay ahead of the curve. Forward this to a colleague who needs to ride the wave and be sure to SUBSCRIBE for continued real estate and business content.