In partnership with
The commercial real estate market is evolving rapidly, and one trend that's impossible to ignore is the explosive growth in auction services. With $50+ billion in annual auction volume and distressed assets hitting $116 billion—up 23% from last year—more clients are asking whether auctions make sense for their deals.
As your broker, I want to give you the straight story on when auctions work brilliantly and when they can backfire spectacularly.
The Auction Boom: By the Numbers
The data tells a compelling story. Crexi Auction achieved a 96% close rate in the first half of 2024, while Ten-X moved $1.6 billion worth of properties in Q1 alone. Properties now attract an average of 18 bidders per auction—nearly double pre-pandemic levels.
But here's what the marketing materials don't always emphasize: success in auctions requires understanding exactly when they're the right tool for your specific situation.
FOR SELLERS: Speed vs. Maximum Price
The Compelling Advantages
Lightning-Fast Closings: While traditional commercial sales can drag on for 6-18 months, auctions typically close in 30-90 days. I recently watched a distressed office building that had been on the market for over a year sell at auction in 75 days with a binding contract.
Competitive Bidding Can Surprise You: The Beach House Golf & Racquet Club in Myrtle Beach started bidding at $700,000 and closed at $3.3 million thanks to competitive auction dynamics. Sometimes the market knows better than we do.
Certainty of Closing: Once that gavel falls, you have a binding contract with a cash buyer. No financing contingencies, no buyer's remorse, no last-minute renegotiations over inspection items.
National Buyer Exposure: Your property gets marketed to investors nationwide through platforms with massive reach, not just local buyers responding to traditional marketing.
The Hard Realities
No Price Guarantees: In absolute auctions, the highest bid wins regardless of value. I've seen quality properties sell for 70% of appraised value because market timing was wrong or bidder turnout was light.
Upfront Costs with No Guarantees: Marketing fees can range from $5,000 to $50,000+ depending on your property, and you pay these whether the property sells or not.
"As-Is" Sales Only: You're selling with no warranties, no repairs, and limited disclosure requirements. This protects you from future claims but may limit your buyer pool.
Loss of Control: Once the auction process starts, you can't adjust pricing strategy, negotiate terms, or pivot to traditional marketing without significant penalties.
FOR BUYERS: Opportunity vs. Risk
The Attractive Opportunities
Below-Market Potential: With $116 billion in distressed assets hitting the market, smart buyers are finding properties at significant discounts to replacement cost.
Transparent Competition: You know exactly who you're competing against and can see bidding in real-time. No more wondering if there's really another offer on the table.
Speed to Market: While other buyers are still arranging financing and conducting months of due diligence, you can close in 30-60 days and start generating returns.
Access to Unique Properties: Many auction properties never hit the traditional market, giving you first access to deals others never see.
The Serious Risks
Compressed Due Diligence: Thirty to sixty days isn't enough time for comprehensive analysis of complex commercial properties. I've seen buyers discover major structural issues, environmental problems, or title defects after closing with no recourse.
Cash or Hard Money Required: Traditional financing rarely works with auction timelines. You need cash or pre-arranged bridge loans, which are expensive and limit your buying power.
Overpayment Risk: Auction fever is real. I've watched bidders get caught up in competition and pay 20-30% over market value for properties they could have bought traditionally for less.
No Contingencies: Once you win, you're committed. No financing contingency, no inspection contingency, no "changed my mind" option. The 10% deposit is typically non-refundable.
When I Recommend Auctions (And When I Don't)
Perfect Auction Scenarios for Sellers:
Your property has been on the market 6+ months with limited activity
You're facing foreclosure or need to liquidate quickly for business reasons
Market conditions are uncertain and traditional pricing is difficult
You're selling a portfolio and need coordinated timing
Auction Red Flags for Sellers:
Your property is unique and requires extensive buyer education
Market conditions favor sellers and traditional sales are moving well
You have specific price requirements that can't be guaranteed
The property has complex issues requiring extensive due diligence
Great Auction Opportunities for Buyers:
You have substantial cash reserves or established hard money relationships
You're experienced in rapid due diligence and comfortable with calculated risks
You're looking for properties in markets where traditional inventory is limited
You can move quickly on opportunities while others are still getting organized
Buyer Beware Situations:
You're new to commercial real estate investing
You need traditional financing or have limited liquidity
The property requires extensive investigation of environmental, title, or structural issues
You're not comfortable with "as-is" purchases
The Bottom Line: Auctions as a Strategic Tool
Commercial real estate auctions aren't magic, but they're powerful tools when used correctly. In today's market—where financing uncertainty is killing traditional deals and inventory is tight—auctions provide essential liquidity for both buyers and sellers willing to trade some control for speed and certainty.
The key is understanding your specific situation and risk tolerance. Auctions work brilliantly for experienced investors with cash looking for opportunities, and for sellers who prioritize speed and certainty over maximum price optimization.
My recommendation: Consider auctions as a complementary strategy, not a replacement for traditional marketing. They're particularly valuable when market conditions create urgency or when traditional approaches aren't generating results.
The auction market momentum is undeniable—major platforms are reporting record close rates and growing transaction volumes. As your broker, I'm here to help you evaluate whether auction services align with your specific goals and circumstances.
Want to discuss whether auction services make sense for your specific property or investment strategy? Let's schedule a consultation to review your options and develop the right approach for your situation.
Contact Brett Vogeler
Your Trusted Commercial Real Estate Advisor
This analysis is based on current market data through Q3 2025 from leading auction platforms including Ten-X, Crexi Auction, and Matthews Real Estate Investment Services.
Please help support this newsletter by simply clicking on the advertising link below and making sure you are subscribed to the newsletter. This is at no cost to you but helps offset the cost of bringing this information to you for FREE!
The Business Brief Executives Actually Trust
In a world of sensational headlines and shallow analysis, The Daily Upside stands apart. Founded by former bankers and seasoned journalists, it delivers crisp, actionable insights executives actually use to make smarter decisions.
From market-moving developments to deep dives on business trends, The Daily Upside gives leaders clarity on what matters — without the noise.
That’s why over 1 million readers, including C-suite executives and senior decision-makers, start their day with it.
No fluff. No spin. Just business clarity.
Book Shelf from Brett Vogeler: amazon.com/author/bvogeler
Need a roadmap? Reply in the comments section or send us an email for assistance. 360 Perspective Partners offers Professional Licensed Business, Commercial and Investment Brokerage Services along with providing Professional Licensed Community Management Services in Central Florida: https://my360perspective.com/
Contact me directly at [email protected]. To see our other useful Newsletters on this topic and others: https://realestate-business-broker-guru.beehiiv.com/
Stay ahead of the curve. Forward this to a colleague who needs to ride the wave and be sure to SUBSCRIBE for continued real estate and business content.