To LLC or Not to LLC? Navigating Commercial Real Estate Purchases

When purchasing commercial real estate, you’re often faced with a pivotal choice: buy the property directly or acquire the Limited Liability Company (LLC) that already owns it. This decision is especially relevant in the commercial space, where properties—think office buildings, retail centers, or industrial warehouses—are commonly held in LLCs for liability protection and tax benefits. Each path offers distinct advantages and trade-offs, from upfront costs and liability exposure to operational continuity and tax implications. Below, we’ll break down both options, focusing on the realities of commercial real estate, so you can decide what aligns best with your business goals, risk tolerance, and financial strategy.

Option 1: Purchasing the LLC That Owns the Property

How It Works

Buying the LLC means purchasing the company’s membership interests, giving you control of the LLC and its asset—the commercial property. The process includes:

• Negotiation: Agree on a price for the LLC’s ownership stakes, often involving multiple members in a commercial deal.

• Due Diligence: Review the LLC’s financials, debts, tenant leases, vendor contracts, and legal obligations.

• Legal Steps: Execute a membership interest purchase agreement, checking the LLC’s operating agreement for transfer rules.

• Closing: Ownership of the LLC transfers to you, with the property remaining under the LLC’s title.

This approach is common in commercial real estate, where existing LLCs streamline ownership transitions.

Advantages

• Lower Upfront Costs: You may avoid real estate transfer taxes (depending on state laws) and the expense of setting up a new LLC, which can cost $200–$300 plus filing fees. This can make it less expensive initially than a direct purchase.

• Operational Continuity: Tenant leases, vendor agreements, and existing financing stay intact, minimizing disruption to cash flow or business operations.

• Liability Protection: The LLC shields your personal assets from property-related risks, like tenant lawsuits or creditor claims.

• Financing Benefits: You can assume existing loans, potentially retaining favorable terms like low interest rates, avoiding the need for new financing.

Disadvantages

• Potential Liabilities: You inherit the LLC’s obligations—debts, legal disputes, or tenant issues—known or hidden, which could offset initial savings.

• Due Diligence Complexity: Investigating the LLC’s full scope requires time and expertise, adding to transaction costs.

• Limited Tax Basis: You take on the LLC’s original tax basis, which may reduce depreciation deductions compared to a direct purchase.

• Ongoing Maintenance: Annual fees and filings for the LLC add administrative responsibilities.

Option 2: Buying the Property Directly

How It Works

A direct purchase means acquiring the property outright, outside of any LLC structure. The steps include:

• Negotiation: Settle on a purchase price with the seller.

• Due Diligence: Assess the property’s title, condition, zoning, and tenant agreements.

• Financing & Contracts: Secure a loan, sign a purchase agreement, and handle any existing debts.

• Closing: The deed transfers to you, granting direct ownership.

If you want liability protection later, you’d need to set up a new LLC and transfer the property into it.

Advantages

• Control and Flexibility: You own the property outright, simplifying decisions about its use, financing, or future sale.

• Tax Benefits: You get a step-up in tax basis to the purchase price, boosting depreciation deductions—a key perk for high-value commercial assets.

• Clean Slate: No inherited liabilities from an existing LLC, reducing exposure to unknown risks.

• Simpler Ownership: Avoids corporate complexities unless you choose to form an LLC later.

Disadvantages

• Higher Upfront Costs: You’ll likely pay transfer taxes (e.g., 0.5% in Florida) and, if you form a new LLC, incur setup costs ($200–$300), making it pricier initially than buying an existing LLC.

• Personal Liability: Without an LLC, your personal assets are at risk from property-related claims or lawsuits.

• Financing Hurdles: New loans may require higher down payments or interest rates compared to assuming an existing LLC’s financing.

• Operational Overhead: Renegotiating tenant leases or contracts could disrupt business continuity.

Key Considerations for Commercial Real Estate

Upfront Costs

• LLC Purchase: Often cheaper initially, as you skip transfer taxes and setup fees for a new LLC—savings that matter in commercial deals where properties are already LLC-held.

• Direct Purchase: Higher upfront costs from taxes and potential LLC formation, though you avoid inherited liabilities that could prove costly later.

Liability

• LLC Purchase: Offers protection but comes with the trade-off of potential liabilities tied to the existing LLC.

• Direct Purchase: Exposes you personally unless you set up a new LLC, adding cost and effort post-purchase.

Tax Implications

• LLC Purchase: Pass-through taxation lets profits and losses flow to your return, but the inherited tax basis may limit depreciation—a factor in commercial properties with significant improvement values.

• Direct Purchase: A step-up in basis maximizes depreciation, potentially lowering taxable income, though you’ll face capital gains on a future sale.

Commercial Context

Most commercial properties are already in LLCs, reflecting owners’ preference for liability protection and tax efficiency. Buying the LLC leverages this existing structure, while a direct purchase requires building your own—potentially duplicating effort and expense.

Quick Comparison

Making Your Decision

Both options suit commercial real estate buyers, depending on priorities:

• Buy the LLC if you value lower upfront costs, operational continuity, and built-in liability protection—ideal for properties with stable tenants and clean financials, despite the risk of inherited liabilities.

• Buy Directly if you prioritize control, tax advantages, and a fresh start—perfect if you’re repositioning the property or wary of unknown risks, even with higher initial costs.

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Consult a real estate attorney and tax advisor to assess state laws, review due diligence findings, and align the choice with your commercial strategy. Whether you opt for the efficiency of an existing LLC or the flexibility of direct ownership, the key is understanding what each path offers—and what it demands—in the context of your goals.

Please help support this newsletter by simply clicking on the advertising link below and making sure you are subscribed to the newsletter. This is at no cost to you but helps offset the cost of bringing this information to you for FREE!

Book Shelf from Brett Vogeler: amazon.com/author/bvogeler

 Need a roadmap? Reply in the comments section or send us an email for assistance.  360 Perspective Partners offers Professional Licensed Business, Commercial and Investment Brokerage Services along with providing Professional Licensed Community Management Services in Central Florida: https://my360perspective.com/

Contact me directly at [email protected]. To see our other useful Newsletters on this topic and others: https://realestate-business-broker-guru.beehiiv.com/

Stay ahead of the curve. Forward this to a colleague who needs to ride the wave and be sure to SUBSCRIBE for continued real estate and business content.